Patents Trade Marks Designs Copyright
Your right to copy competitor products – questions to ask oneself
November 18, 2026
Envious of a competitor’s product? Interested in a brochure for a Chinese-made product but concerned it might be a copy of someone’s product? We can conduct targeted ‘freedom to operate’ risk assessments and advise you whether something is risky or not.
Are you free to copy a competitor’s product?
Typical scenarios: You wish to launch a copy or similar version of a competitor’s product in the UK. The products will be made in the UK or made in China and shipped to the UK. Perhaps this was your idea, or perhaps your supplier showed you a brochure depicting products that look a lot like products sold by your competitor.
Below is a (non-exhaustive) list of checks, some or all of which may be considered by one of our chartered patent or trade mark attorneys during a freedom to operate (FTO) risk assessment.
The below checks are too complex and require too much knowledge of intellectual property law to be performed by a non-expert. The objective of this article is to show why skim-reading just one randomly-discovered patent or design falls far short of a proper risk assessment, and why a proper attorney-led risk assessment is essential (and very useful).
Patents
Type of protection = Inventive concepts such as product functionality.
Who developed the invention? = Was it the competitor or an unrelated third-party? Or multiple entities in collaboration? This affects who the owner is.
Ownership = Owned by the competitor? Or parent companies, child companies, sister companies? An individual such as a director? Or, an unrelated licensor? Has the company changed names over the years? This affects who the owner is.
Number of patents = Is there more than one patent covering the product? Are there any divisional patents? How has the product changed over the years? Are there recent patents for recent versions of the product? This affects how long their patent protection lasts for and what aspects are covered.
Territories = Does the patent portfolio cover the UK? Does it cover the country of your supplier (e.g., China)? Do they have the same scope of protection in each country?
Age = Has it expired? Typically, but not always, this is 20 or 21 years from original filing.
Status = Is it pending or granted and are any renewal fees up to date? If rights have been lost, can the rights still be restored?
Scope of protection = What does the patent actually cover? What do the independent and dependent claims of the patent say? What equivalents does the patent cover? Is there a way of working around the patent’s scope of protection?
Validity = Is the patent valid? Did they self-disclose the invention before the filing date? Was the invention disclosed in other prior art before the filing date? Is the claimed invention obvious? Is the description of the invention sufficiently detailed? Is their priority claim valid? Does the patent contain added subject matter? Is the invention an excluded invention? Assess on a claim-by-claim basis.
Availability = Is the patent(s) available to licence or purchase? Is the company available to purchase or collaborate with?
Registered Designs
Type of protection = The aesthetic appearance of the whole or part of the product.
Who created the design? = Was it the competitor or an unrelated third-party? Or multiple entities in collaboration? This affects who the owner is.
Ownership = Owned by the competitor? Or parent companies, child companies, sister companies? An individual such as a director? Or, an unrelated licensor? Has the company changed names over the years? This affects who the owner is.
Number of designs = Is there more than one registered design covering the product? Is the registration for a ‘multiple design’? How has the product changed over the years? Are there recent registered designs for recent versions of the product? This affects how long their design protection lasts for and what aspects are covered.
Territories = Does the design portfolio cover the UK? Does it cover the country of your supplier (e.g., China)? Is it an International (Hague) Design? Do they have the same scope of protection in each country?
Age = Has it expired? This varies from 10 to 25 years from filing depending on the country.
Status = Is it pending or granted and are any renewal fees up to date? If rights have been lost, can the rights still be restored?
Scope of protection = What is the ‘overall impression’ of the design? How does it differ from the ‘design corpus’? Is there a way of working around the design’s scope of protection?
Validity = Is the registered design valid? Did they self-disclose the design before the filing date (taking into account any grace period)? Was the design disclosed by a third party before the filing date/grace period? Does the design have individual character? Is the design solely dictated by technical function? Is the design directed to a ‘must-fit’ product, and if so is it a modular product? Is the design of a part of a complex product visible in normal use? What is normal use? Is the design an excluded type of design? Is their priority claim valid? Has the design changed after filing? Are the views inconsistent so that they don’t all show the same design?
Availability = Is the registered design(s) available to licence or purchase? Is the company available to purchase or collaborate with?
Unregistered design rights
Type of protection = Unregistered right related to direct copying and imitation.
Copying? = Did your designer have knowledge of the competitor product at the relevant time? Unregistered design rights can only be infringed by copying.
Who created the design? = Was it the competitor or an unrelated third-party? Or multiple entities in collaboration? This affects who the owner is.
Ownership = Owned by the competitor? Or parent companies, child companies, sister companies? An individual such as a director? Or, an unrelated licensor? Has the company changed names over the years? Who qualifies for ownership in the UK (designer, first marketer, etc)? This affects who the owner is.
Number of designs = How has the product changed over the years? Are there recent unregistered design rights for recent versions of the product? This affects how long their design protection lasts for and what aspects are covered.
Territories = Was the designer or their employer from the UK? Was it first marketed in the relevant territories?
Age = Has it expired? Is a licence of right available? The UK right lasts 10 or 15 years, with a licence of right available within the last 5 years.
Scope of protection = What would count as copying? Do you intend to copy part of their design or their whole design?
Validity = Is the design original over prior designs? Does it comply with the definition of a design? Is the design a ‘must-fit’ or ‘must-match’ design? Consider any earlier disclosures by the competitor or third parties.
Availability = Is the design right(s) available to licence or purchase? Is the company available to purchase or collaborate with?
Other jurisdictions = do the other relevant countries have an unregistered design system or analogous unfair competition law system? Consider relevance.
Copyright
Type of protection = Dramatic, musical, literary, or artistic works. For products, artistic works may include decoration and surface ornamentation. Some particularly aesthetic product shapes may be protected as artistic works (sculptures or works of artistic craftsmanship).
Copying? = Did your designer have knowledge of the competitor product at the relevant time? Copyright can only be infringed by copying.
Who created the work? = Was it the competitor or an unrelated third-party? Or multiple entities in collaboration? This affects who the owner is.
Ownership = Owned by the competitor? Or parent companies, child companies, sister companies? An individual such as a director? Or, an unrelated licensor? Has the company changed names over the years? This affects who the owner is.
Number of works = How has the product changed over the years? Is there recent copyright for recent versions of the product? This affects how long their copyright lasts for and what versions of the work are covered.
Territories = Was it created in a Berne convention country? (usually yes)
Registration = Has the copyright been registered in countries that require registration of copyright?
Age = Has it expired? UK copyright typically lasts 70 years starting from the death of the author, but this may vary with the type of work and country.
Scope of protection = What would count as copying? Do you intend to copy part of their work or their whole work? Do you intend to use their decorative elements?
Validity = Is the copyright original over prior disclosures? Consider any earlier disclosures by the competitor or third parties.
Availability = Is the copyright available to licence or purchase? Is the company available to purchase or collaborate with?
Registered trade marks / passing off
Trade marks are outside the scope of the present article. Our chartered trade mark attorneys can assess trade mark risk. You should pay particular attention to trade marks if you wish to copy a competitor company name, brand name, packaging or get-up, and any other distinctive signs which may even include the product shape.
Trade secrets/confidential information
Trade secrets and confidential information are outside the scope of the present article. However, they may be relevant in some cases such as working outside a confidentiality agreement or taking on employees from a competitor.
Other less common IP rights
Less common IP rights include plant breeders rights, semiconductor topography rights, supplementary protection certificates, certification marks, geographical indications of origin, among other things.
How we help
Our chartered patent and trade mark attorneys can help to conduct proper freedom to operate (FTO) risk assessments:
- Initial company investigations to find out the names affiliated with a particular competitor, in whose names IP rights may be held;
- Finding any IP relevant to the competitor product, using a combination of registered IP searches and desk studies of any unregistered rights;
- Reviewing whether competitor IP is infringed by your planned product;
- Advising how to avoid infringement, for example by redesign or avoiding certain territories or product features;
- Reviewing potential grounds for invalidity of competitor IP;
- Finding leverage or counterattacks that could be used against the competitor if they come after you;
- Helping to licence in or acquire third-party IP;
- Connecting you with insurers who can insure you against IP risk;
- Connecting you with solicitors who can help to limit your contractual exposure to IP risk.