Patents
R&D tax relief claims: How patents can help
November 18, 2026
UK companies can strengthen their R&D tax relief claims using patents and patent applications. This article discusses the role of patents, patent applications, and UKIPO search reports as structured, credible evidence of inventive activity, providing crucial support for R&D tax relief claims amid increased HMRC scrutiny.
Why does UK law apply to you?
Intellectual property (IP) rights are territorial, so a UK registered design can only be enforced within the UK. However, major platforms like Amazon™, eBay™, and Etsy™ operate globally. If your listings are available to UK buyers, a UK registered design holder can report them as infringing their IP, and the platform will act on that report regardless of where you're based – even if it’s the other side of the Atlantic!
UK registered designs vs. US design patents
In the US, protecting a product's appearance requires a 'design patent'. Obtaining one involves an examination process during which the USPTO assesses whether the design is new and non-obvious. This can take years.
The UK equivalent, a registered design, protects appearance including shape, configuration, and colour. But there is a critical difference: the UKIPO grants registered designs without examining whether the design is actually new. Applications are checked for formalities only, and protection can be granted within days.
This makes the UK system vulnerable to abuse. In recent years there has been a notable rise in ‘bad-faith’ registrations by competitors seeking to exploit platform IP policies for commercial advantage.
Why many of these registrations are weaker than they look
When a platform issues a takedown notice, it is following its own internal policies – not making any judgment on whether the registered design is valid, or importantly, whether your listing is even infringing it. In most cases, the registration behind your notice is weaker than it appears, for one or more of the following reasons:
- The design isn't new. If the same design was publicly available before the registration date (i.e., on a manufacturer's website, an Amazon™ listing, or anywhere accessible to the public) the registration may be invalid. If you were selling the same or a similar product before the registration date, that history can itself be valuable evidence.
- The design doesn't cover your product. A registered design only protects the specific appearance shown in the registration. If your product looks sufficiently different, there may be no infringement irrespective of whether the registered design is valid or not.
- The registration was made in bad faith. To validly hold a registered design, you must be the original creator. If a competitor simply registered a design for a product they didn't create, that is a straightforward ground for invalidation.
What can you do?
Ignoring a takedown notice is not a viable strategy. Platforms can suspend your listing, de-rank your shop, or remove it entirely. Broadly speaking, you have four options:
- Ask the platform to arbitrate – some platforms will act if a claim is clearly frivolous, or if you agree to disable UK shipping.
- Negotiate with the rights holder – agreeing to disable UK shipping may be a pragmatic short-term fix, though it leaves the registration in place.
- Challenge through the courts – possible, but expensive and rarely practical for a US seller with no UK presence.
- Apply to the UKIPO for invalidation – an administrative process, handled entirely remotely, which if successful removes the registration from the register entirely.
For most US sellers, we recommend option 4, approached in stages: first a formal legal opinion (which platforms like Amazon™ will often accept as part of a counter-notice); then a letter to the rights holder putting them on notice of our intention to apply for invalidation; and if necessary, applying for invalidation. A successful invalidation also opens the door to a damages claim under UK unjustified threats law.
What evidence do you need?
The key is evidence that the same or a very similar design was publicly available before the registration date. This evidence must contain two things: i) an image of the earlier design, and ii) a verifiable date. Useful sources include web archives and your own sales records where invoices include product images.
Concluding remarks
Many of these registrations are weak, hastily filed, and would not survive a proper challenge. The UK system provides a relatively low-cost route to contest them, and as a US seller you are not excluded from using it. If you have received a takedown notice, act quickly and seek proper advice.
If you have any questions regarding this article, or would like further assistance, please contact your usual Swindell & Pearson attorney or Dan Hanna, the author of this article.