Patents
Patents combined with trade secrets - having your cake and eating it
November 20, 2026
Patents protect inventions but require disclosure, while trade secrets allow confidentiality but offer no formal monopoly. Often seen as mutually exclusive, with careful IP strategy and professional guidance, the two can work together more than most people think.
You can't have your cake and eat it – or can you?
IP protection is more strategic than most people realise. Businesses invest substantial time, expertise, and resources into developing innovative products and processes. Naturally, they want protection. But protection often requires disclosure – and disclosure can feel uncomfortable.
Patents and trade secrets feel like mutually exclusive forms of protection. You can patent your invention and disclose it to the world, or you can keep it secret. But can you do both, and to what extent?
Patents
A patent is often thought of as a "bargain with the state". An inventor discloses their invention to the public and in return receives a period of protection (typically 20 years from filing) during which others cannot make, use, or sell the patented invention without permission.
This system incentivises innovation. A business that has invested significantly in developing an invention can prevent competitors from simply copying it. However, the bargain has consequences. Patent applications are typically published 18 months after filing, at which point competitors can see exactly how the invention works. And if the application is ultimately refused, you will have disclosed your invention without receiving any protection in return.
Trade secrets
A trade secret is information kept confidential to provide a competitive edge. To qualify, the information must i) be secret, ii) have commercial value because it is secret, and iii) be subject to reasonable steps to maintain confidentiality.
The classic example is the Coca-Cola recipe. By keeping the formulation confidential, Coca-Cola ensures competitors cannot reproduce the exact product. This protection can last indefinitely, of course, the risk being that this protection is lost if the information is independently discovered, reverse engineered, or leaked.
So can you have your cake and eat it?
Companies often face a genuine dilemma: they want legal protection for their innovations, but they don't want to disclose valuable technical know-how. A significant advantage of working with an experienced IP professional is understanding the nuances of what constitutes a "sufficient disclosure”.
A patent application must disclose the invention clearly enough for a skilled person to perform it. However, it does not need to disclose everything learned in the course of developing it.
An illustrative example
Consider a vehicle manufacturer that develops a novel algorithm controlling the level of assistance torque in a power-assisted steering system (often perceived by the driver as the “lightness” of the steering). The relationship between steering assistance and vehicle speed forms the inventive concept. However, the precise calibration values used in the algorithm, which have been optimised through extensive testing and driver feedback, represent valuable technical know-how.
The top graph shows the precise relationship in full detail. The bottom shows a modified version suitable for a patent application: axis numbering removed, exact velocities omitted, gridlines stripped, line shapes generalised, and vertical magnitudes made arbitrary so that the relative scales of the lines cannot be derived by measurement. The number of lines has also been reduced, leaving open how many speeds the controller is calibrated for.
Including the top graph in full would allow a competitor to extract the calibrations simply by analysing it. The bottom version obfuscates exact calibration values allowing that information to be kept as a trade secret, whilst still disclosing the inventive concept (i.e., the existence and nature of the relationship).
This is where strategic drafting becomes critical. Too little disclosure risks insufficiency and subsequent refusal of the patent application. Too much gives away commercially valuable information unnecessarily. An IP professional can help determine what must be disclosed and what may safely remain secret.
Other examples
Another example of strategic disclosure might involve a chemical formulation. Suppose a company develops a novel cleaning solution whose effectiveness depends on a specific concentration of an active ingredient. The company may wish to patent the formulation while keeping as much secret as possible. In the patent, we would only provide specific values for the inventive active ingredient, but would describe the other ingredients more broadly or not mention them at all. This approach discloses the inventive concept (the novel composition) while giving away as little else as possible.
Similarly, in the AI domain, consider a system designed to detect facial expressions. The inventive concept may lie in the core algorithm that maps facial movements to expressions. The patent could focus on this algorithm without detailing every feature. For example, we could withhold disclosure of certain add-on modules designed to prevent false positives (e.g., mechanisms that avoid triggering updates every time a person moves). By withholding these optimisation details, the patent discloses how to make a very basic version of the software, while the company retains trade secrets in the specific hidden features that make the product work smoothly in the real world.
Accelerated examination: a strategic tool
There is one further dimension worth considering. If it becomes unclear whether an invention is patentable, an applicant may prefer to keep the whole concept secret rather than risk disclosure without protection.
In many jurisdictions it is possible to request accelerated examination, allowing the patent office to provide early feedback before publication at the 18-month stage. If it becomes clear the patent is unlikely to be granted on terms you would be happy with (or rather, terms that make the invention worth disclosing to the public), the application can be withdrawn before publication – and the invention protected as a trade secret instead.
Concluding remarks
A common misconception is that patenting an invention means giving away everything. While it’s true that you must disclose the underlying inventive concept, smart IP strategy ensures you don’t have to reveal every detail.
With careful drafting and guidance from an IP professional, you can protect the core of your innovation while potentially keeping the implementation secrets that provide a real competitive edge.
You may not be able to fully “have your cake and eat it,” but with the right approach, you can come much closer than most think.
If you have any questions regarding this article, or would like further assistance, please contact your usual Swindell & Pearson attorney or Dan Hanna, the author of this article.